Expert Hire vs Humanly
Compare Expert Hire and Humanly for AI-powered recruiting. Discover why teams choose Expert Hire over Humanly for deeper AI interviews, proctoring, and full hiring automation.
Overview
Expert Hire
Expert Hire is an AI-powered hiring platform built by staffing industry veterans with 20+ years of experience and incubated at IIT Madras. It offers AI-powered live interviews with contextual follow-up questions, human-to-human proctored interview rounds with AI-suggested questions for interviewers, bulk resume screening with contextual matching, a desktop app for strict-proctoring rounds, a Chrome extension for resume redaction and candidate import, and multi-lingual interview support.
Humanly
Humanly is a conversational AI recruiting platform that automates candidate engagement through chat-based screening, interview scheduling, and note-taking during live interviews. It focuses on creating equitable hiring through consistent AI-driven conversations and reducing bias in the screening process.
Why teams switch from Humanly to Expert Hire
Feature Comparison
| Feature |  Expert Hire |  Humanly |
|---|---|---|
| Interviews | ||
| AI-conducted full interviews | ||
| Chat-based screening | ||
| Human-to-human proctored rounds | ||
| AI-suggested interview questions | ||
| Multi-lingual interviews | ||
| AI interview note-taking | ||
| Resume Screening | ||
| AI resume screening | Bulk AI screening | |
| Resume data redaction (Chrome extension) | ||
| Proctoring | ||
| AI proctoring | AI-powered + desktop app | |
| Platform | ||
| Interview scheduling automation | ||
| Desktop application | ||
| Chrome extension | ||
| Candidate sourcing | Coming soon | |
| Analytics | ||
| Bias reduction tools | ||
| Candidate scoring | ||
| Integration | ||
| ATS integrations | Greenhouse (early access) | |
| Assessments | ||
| Programming language support | All popular languages | |
AI-conducted full interviews
Chat-based screening
Human-to-human proctored rounds
AI-suggested interview questions
Multi-lingual interviews
AI interview note-taking
AI resume screening
Bulk AI screeningResume data redaction (Chrome extension)
AI proctoring
AI-powered + desktop appInterview scheduling automation
Desktop application
Chrome extension
Candidate sourcing
Coming soonBias reduction tools
Candidate scoring
ATS integrations
Greenhouse (early access)Programming language support
All popular languagesDetailed Comparison
Evaluation Depth
Expert HireExpert Hire conducts full AI-powered interviews with contextual follow-up questioning that probes technical skills, problem-solving ability, communication, and cultural fit. Live coding tests use contextual AI questioning rather than just test case passing. Multi-lingual support enables global evaluations.
HumanlyHumanly conducts chat-based screening conversations that efficiently qualify candidates on basic criteria. The conversational format is quick but limited in evaluation depth compared to full interviews.
Expert Hire's full AI interviews provide significantly deeper candidate evaluation than Humanly's chat-based screening.
Bias Reduction
Expert HireExpert Hire applies consistent evaluation criteria across all candidates, which reduces interviewer bias. You get consistent, reviewable scoring records to support your own fairness monitoring.
HumanlyHumanly was designed with equity at its core, providing consistent screening conversations that reduce bias in initial candidate engagement. It offers analytics to track hiring equity metrics.
Both platforms prioritize bias reduction through AI consistency. Humanly's equity-first design is a core differentiator, while Expert Hire's AI consistency achieves similar fairness goals.
Interview Support
Expert HireExpert Hire proctors human-to-human interviews in real time via its desktop app for strict-proctoring rounds, while providing AI-suggested questions for interviewers based on how the candidate responds during the conversation.
HumanlyHumanly provides AI note-taking and summarization during live interviews, helping interviewers capture key points without manual note-taking. It does not proctor or grade interviews.
Expert Hire's proctoring and grading during human interviews goes further than Humanly's note-taking, providing evaluation assistance alongside documentation.
Candidate Engagement Breadth
Expert HireExpert Hire engages candidates through AI interviews, prep dashboards, and multi-platform access. Its engagement is evaluation-focused and occurs during the active assessment phase.
HumanlyHumanly engages candidates from initial outreach through screening, scheduling, and post-interview follow-up via conversational AI. Its engagement spans a broader portion of the candidate journey.
Humanly's conversational approach provides broader candidate engagement across more touchpoints in the hiring journey.
Platform Completeness
Expert HireExpert Hire covers bulk resume screening, AI interviews with contextual follow-ups, live coding tests, human-to-human proctored rounds with AI-suggested questions, desktop app proctoring, and analytics in a unified platform. The Chrome extension enables resume redaction and candidate import.
HumanlyHumanly focuses on conversational engagement, screening, and interview assistance. Comprehensive assessments, resume screening, and proctoring require additional tools.
Expert Hire's broader feature set covers more of the hiring evaluation pipeline than Humanly's conversation-focused approach.
Pricing Comparison
Expert Hire
Free Trial ($0 for 30 days), then one credit pool from $99/mo with unlimited team members. Starter at $249/mo, Growth at $499/mo, and custom Scale pricing.
Humanly
Custom pricing based on company size and usage. Typically requires a demo and sales engagement for pricing details.
Pricing Verdict: Expert Hire offers transparent pricing with broader evaluation features. Humanly's pricing is custom and focused on conversational engagement. Expert Hire typically delivers more evaluation functionality per dollar.
Final Verdict
3
Expert Hire Wins
1
Ties
1
Humanly Wins
Choose Expert Hire if you need...
- Live coding tests with contextual AI questioning that adapts based on candidate responses, not just test case passing.
- Human-to-human interview rounds with AI-assisted proctoring and real-time question suggestions for interviewers.
- Cross-platform desktop app for strict-proctoring rounds, with signals surfaced to a human reviewer.
- Chrome extension for easy resume redaction and candidate import into the Expert Hire platform.
- Multi-lingual interview support for evaluating diverse, global talent pools.
- Bulk resume screening, with a Greenhouse connector in early access and more ATS connectors on the roadmap.
- Built by staffing industry veterans with 20+ years of recruiting experience, incubated at IIT Madras.
Humanly may work if...
- You specifically need a specialized conversational ai recruiting platform and nothing else
- Your team is already invested in their ecosystem and switching cost is high
- You don't require AI-powered proctoring, live coding interviews, or resume screening in the same platform
Frequently Asked Questions
Ready to switch from Humanly?
Join teams who have upgraded their hiring process with Expert Hire. Start with a free trial and see the difference.
Other Comparisons
Ribbon is an AI-powered phone screening tool that automates initial candidate phone screens. It conducts conversational phone interviews with candidates, evaluates their responses, and provides recruiters with summaries and scores to help identify qualified candidates quickly.
Compare
Kore.ai is a general-purpose conversational AI platform that enables enterprises to build AI-powered virtual assistants across various use cases including HR, IT, and customer service. Its HR module can automate candidate engagement, FAQ responses, and basic screening through chatbot interactions.
Compare
Alex is an AI-powered virtual recruiter that automates candidate outreach, engagement, and screening. It handles repetitive recruiting tasks like sourcing, messaging candidates, scheduling interviews, and initial qualification, acting as a virtual recruiting assistant that works alongside human recruiters.
Compare